Is PTSD In Women Different Than In Men?
Historically, research on trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) focused on men, with many studies centered on how male combat veterans responded to war-related trauma. These studies and public understanding led to the bias that only men or veterans experience PTSD. Women were often not considered in these initial studies. However, recent studies reveal that women are twice as likely to experience PTSD as men.
PTSD symptoms in women are also different, and the causes are commonly associated more with abuse or sexual assault than combat violence. To understand why PTSD can look different in women, it may be valuable to understand further the distinctive ways many women report their symptoms and the various treatment options available to women living with this condition.
What is PTSD?
Post-traumatic stress disorder is a mental health condition that occurs after an individual has experienced a particularly traumatizing situation or experience, whether firsthand or indirectly. Multiple traumatic events can also contribute to PTSD. Anyone with any background or identity can develop PTSD, and each person may react differently to a similar type of traumatic event.
It may be helpful to think of PTSD as an extreme psychological defense mechanism. It is connected to the fight-or-flight response and chronic stress, which is why it is listed in the DSM-5 as a trauma and stressor-related disorder. Some individuals may have an increased risk of developing PTSD due to a genetic predisposition or pre-existing mental health concerns that may impair their ability to cope with a traumatic event.
About 60% of men and 50% of women experience trauma during their lifetimes, and 7% to 8% of these individuals are diagnosed with PTSD because of their experiences. For some, symptoms can resolve quickly. For others, symptoms may last months or years. When PTSD is chronic and long-term, caused by repeated traumas over several years, therapists may refer to the condition as complex PTSD or C-PTSD. However, C-PTSD is not listed in the DSM-5 currently.
What are the symptoms of PTSD?
Symptoms of PTSD often do not appear immediately after a traumatic incident has taken place. It may surface a few months to a year after the triggering event. For someone to be diagnosed with PTSD, they must showcase symptoms for at least 30 days and exhibit symptoms from the following categories:
- Re-Experiencing: Nightmares, flashbacks, and frightening thoughts related to the traumatic event or events
- Avoidance: Avoidance of places, people, objects, ideas, or situations that are reminders of the trauma, or avoidance of thoughts and feelings
- Arousal And Reaction: Tense muscles, emotional outbursts, disturbed sleep patterns, agitation, hyperarousal, hypervigilance
- Mood And Cognitive Symptoms: Loss of interest in previously-enjoyed activities, distressing thoughts, memory gaps, or dissociation
The symptoms of PTSD can interfere with one's ability to function in daily life. Many people with the condition have "triggers," which are ideas, sounds, scents, situations, stimuli, or other factors that cause memories or reminders of the traumatic event or events experienced. Reminders of the trauma might cause anxiety, panic, dissociation, anger, or crying, among other symptoms. As a result, PTSD can make interacting with others difficult and may impact interpersonal relationships.
PTSD can lead to personality changes, difficulty in the workplace, decreased ability to function in daily life, substance use, mental health conditions, and trouble maintaining relationships with friends and family, among other consequences.
Common causes of PTSD in women
People of all genders with PTSD may experience symptoms and traumas in common. However, researchers have found that women are more likely to experience specific traumas than other genders. Men, however, are more likely to be diagnosed with PTSD after military-related traumas, accidents, natural disasters, or work-related trauma.
This statistic doesn't mean men don't face PTSD from other factors. Many men tend to keep quiet about abuse and not divulge that it has happened to them, which can lead to fewer men reaching out for support. In addition, studies have found that men face unique stigmas in asking for help, which can deter them from participating in studies about these conditions.
Women are also more likely to have a pre-existing condition, such as depression or an anxiety disorder, which increases their susceptibility to developing PTSD. While about 4% of all men may develop post-traumatic stress disorder at some point in their lives, 10% of women are diagnosed.
How sex and gender affect symptoms of PTSD
According to extensive research regarding the incidence of PTSD, sex and gender have different effects on how people process trauma and manage symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder. Individual gender roles, genetic predisposition, and hormonal influences may all impact how individuals present their PTSD symptoms.
Emotional impacts
Men may be more likely to experience traumatic events during their lives, but the types of traumas that women face and how they react to them have led to a higher occurrence of PTSD in women. Gender roles related to masculinity may influence these behaviors, with men showing avoidant, problem-solving, or anger-related responses to trauma.
In contrast, trauma affects women more intimately on an emotional level, and they are more likely to continue reprocessing their traumas, which can lead to PTSD. Men may attempt to cope with trauma by engaging in substance use and are more prone to angry outbursts, though many women also turn to substances and experience violent behavior.
Types of trauma
The specific types of abuse or trauma that women often live through can increase fearfulness, anxiety, avoidance, and depression. Women with PTSD are often survivors of specific types of abuse, which can highly impair their daily lives. Fear and mistrust of others can be common in these cases.
Sexual abuse and assault are the leading causes of PTSD in women, although men can also experience these types of abuse. Sexual abuse can have lasting adverse effects, especially when it takes place during childhood while the brain is still developing. In some people, it can cause increased long-term fear and impact one's ability to control their emotions throughout their lifetime.
Women who have experienced abuse or sexual assault may struggle to avoid their trauma triggers, as sex and intimacy are involved in many peoples' lives. These traumas can lead to triggers within relationships or family life, including while pregnant or visiting the doctor. In addition, women often face gender-related violence and harmful comments and behaviors from others that can remind them of their traumas.
Why do some people with the same traumas have PTSD when others do not?
Each person may react differently to traumatic incidents. However, mental health and social support can impact how people manage these experiences. A person's support system before and after experiencing a traumatic event, their mental state, and their overall health are significant factors in determining whether they will develop PTSD in response to trauma.
For example, a person not living with a mental health condition can still experience PTSD after being involved in a traumatic incident. However, they may have fewer obstacles to overcome in the coping process and could have a better chance of moving past their trauma faster.
In addition, a person who experiences abuse from their family and lacks a support system may be more likely to develop PTSD than someone who has a solid support system and feels loved. Due to a lack of social support, people who feel isolated or alone may struggle to cope and move on from the incident or events. In contrast, people with healthy relationships may feel adequately supported through their trauma and can rely on others to comfort them when they're afraid.
People already experiencing one or more significant mental health conditions may find themselves more susceptible to the effects of trauma, making them more likely to develop PTSD. For example, people who have experienced trauma during childhood or prolonged, chronic, or severe traumas have a significantly higher chance of developing PTSD than those who may have had an isolated traumatic incident during adulthood.
Those struggling with substance use may also be more likely to have trouble processing trauma, particularly if their substance use is related to underlying mental health factors. The symptoms of mental illnesses like depression and anxiety can be exacerbated when a situation as impactful as trauma occurs.
Treatment for PTSD and its symptoms
The most effective way to manage PTSD is to seek professional support. Many women are more likely to seek help after a traumatic incident and benefit from it compared to men because they may feel more comfortable being open and honest about their thoughts and emotions.
A mental health professional may use various methods to treat someone with PTSD as they work to understand their trauma and associated symptoms. However, not every method will work for every person. Below are a few common modalities used:
- Exposure and response prevention therapy (ERP)
- Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing therapy (EMDR)
- Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT)
- Cognitive-processing therapy (CPT)
- Internal family systems therapy (IFS)
- Medications
For some, treatment may be effective and resolve symptoms within a short period. For others, treatment may take months or years. The types of therapy available for PTSD may not benefit everyone, so many therapists take an integrative approach to PTSD, treating symptoms with various modalities.
Note: Before starting, changing, or stopping any medication, consult a medical provider like a psychiatrist or primary care physician. In most states, counselors, social workers, therapists, and psychologists cannot prescribe or manage medication.
Alternative counseling options
If you or someone you know has experienced trauma or is trying to cope with PTSD, or if you feel you may have symptoms of PTSD after experiencing a traumatic incident, consider seeking professional support. Managing symptoms of PTSD can make daily living tasks and relationships challenging. Allowing yourself to express your feelings, experiences, and thoughts after trauma may be a beneficial coping mechanism.
If you cannot make an appointment with a therapist in person due to scheduling issues or convenience, consider online therapy. Research has shown that online therapy can be as beneficial as and more convenient than in-person therapy. For example, an extensive review published in Cureus explored the efficacy of online cognitive-behavioral therapy. The results showed that the treatment could be more effective than in-person therapy for treating post-traumatic stress disorder and co-morbid conditions like anxiety and depression.
Valuable resources and licensed professionals can be obtained through online platforms like BetterHelp. You can connect with a mental health professional for guidance over the phone, via video chat, or through a live messaging session with your therapist. In addition, when you sign up, you can note whether you're interested in meeting with a trauma-informed therapist or someone with experience treating PTSD.
Takeaway
What are the signs of PTSD in women?
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) can affect all genders, and while the core symptoms are similar, some research suggests that women may experience certain PTSD symptoms and comorbid conditions more frequently. It's important to remember that the experience of PTSD is highly individualized, and not all women will exhibit the same signs and symptoms. Only a certified mental health professional can diagnose PTSD by comprehensively evaluating an individual using a PTSD checklist, however, some common signs of PTSD in women may include:
Re-experiencing symptoms:
- Flashbacks: Vivid and distressing flashbacks of the traumatic event(s).
- Nightmares: Frequent nightmares related to the trauma.
- Avoidance of Triggers: Going to great lengths to avoid reminders of the trauma.
- Emotional Numbing: Difficulty experiencing positive emotions and feeling emotionally detached.
Hyperarousal and reactivity:
- Irritability: Easily becoming irritable or having outbursts of anger.
- Hypervigilance: Feeling constantly on high alert.
- Exaggerated Startle Response: Reacting strongly to sudden noises or unexpected events.
- Sleep Disturbances: Insomnia, frequent awakenings, and nightmares.
Negative changes in mood and cognition:
- Negative Self-Perception: Persistent negative beliefs about themselves, others, or the world.
- Guilt and Shame: Feelings of guilt or shame related to the traumatic event(s).
- Detachment: Emotional detachment from others and a sense of isolation or other mood symptoms.
Changes in relationships:
Difficulty in Relationships: Struggles in forming and maintaining relationships, often due to avoidance behaviors, emotional numbness, and communication difficulties.
Mood Disorders: Women with PTSD may be more likely to experience comorbid mood disorders such as depression and anxiety.
Physical Symptoms: Some women with PTSD may experience physical symptoms such as headaches, gastrointestinal problems, or chronic pain.
Increased Risk of Revictimization: Research has suggested that women with a history of trauma, including PTSD, may be at a higher risk of experiencing trauma or interpersonal violence.
What is the most common trauma for women?
The most common traumatic experiences for women can vary depending on factors such as geographical location, cultural context, and individual circumstances. Trauma can result from a wide range of events, and what is considered the most common trauma can differ from one region or population to another. However, several types of traumatic experiences are more commonly reported among women:
- Sexual assault and abuse: Sexual assault and childhood sexual abuse are significant traumas that many women experience. These experiences can have profound and long-lasting effects on survivors.
- Domestic Violence: Intimate partner violence, including physical, emotional, and psychological abuse, is a prevalent trauma that affects many women. Domestic violence can occur in various forms, such as physical abuse, emotional manipulation, and controlling behaviors.
- Childhood trauma: Childhood abuse or traumas, including neglect, physical abuse, emotional abuse, and witnessing domestic violence, can impact women throughout their lives. Childhood trauma can contribute to mental health challenges in adulthood.
- Natural disasters: Women, like men, can experience trauma as a result of natural disasters, such as hurricanes, earthquakes, floods, and wildfires.
- Medical trauma: Some women may experience trauma related to medical procedures, surgeries, or life-threatening illnesses. This can lead to medical PTSD or trauma-related to healthcare experiences.
- Combat trauma: Women in the military can experience combat-related trauma, including exposure to violence and combat operations.
- Human trafficking: Human trafficking, including sex trafficking and labor trafficking, is a traumatic experience that disproportionately affects women and girls.
- Community violence: Exposure to community violence, such as gun violence or witnessing violent crimes or violent death, can also be a source of trauma for women.
- Loss and grief: The loss of a loved one through death or other circumstances can be a traumatic experience that affects women deeply.
Why is PTSD higher in women?
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is more commonly diagnosed in women than in men, and there are several factors that may contribute to this higher prevalence in women. It's important to note that while women are more frequently diagnosed with PTSD, men can also experience this condition, and both genders deserve appropriate care and support. Here are some factors that may help explain why there are gender differences in the PTSD rates for women and men:
- Prevalence of traumatic experiences: Women may be more likely to experience certain types of traumatic events, such as sexual violence, that are associated with a higher risk of developing PTSD. For example, sexual assault and domestic violence are traumatic experiences that disproportionately affect women and can lead to PTSD.
- Greater likelihood of childhood trauma: Women may have a higher likelihood of experiencing childhood trauma, such as physical or sexual abuse, which can increase the risk of PTSD later in life.
- Social and cultural factors: Societal and cultural factors can play a role. Gender-based violence and discrimination can contribute to trauma in women, as can societal expectations related to caregiving and emotional expression.
- Biological differences: Some research suggests that hormonal and neurobiological differences between genders may influence the risk of developing PTSD and the way symptoms are experienced.
- Social support networks: Women often have stronger social support networks and are more likely to seek help for their mental health concerns. While this can be a defensive factor, it may also lead to higher rates of diagnosis.
- Reporting bias: There may be a reporting bias, where women are more likely to tell their traumatic experiences and seek help, while men may be less likely to do so due to stigma or traditional gender roles.
- Complex trauma: Women may be more likely to experience complex trauma, which involves repeated or prolonged exposure to traumatic events. Complex trauma is associated with a higher risk of developing PTSD.
- Comorbid conditions: Women with PTSD may be more likely to have comorbid mental health conditions, such as depression and anxiety, which can increase the likelihood of seeking treatment and receiving a PTSD diagnosis.
Can a woman with PTSD fall in love?
Yes, a woman with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) can fall in love and have healthy and fulfilling relationships. PTSD is a mental health condition that affects an individual's emotional and psychological well-being but does not prevent them from experiencing love, forming connections, and maintaining meaningful relationships.
It's important to remember that individuals with PTSD, like anyone else, have the capacity to experience love and romantic feelings. However, they may face unique challenges related to their PTSD symptoms, such as hypervigilance, emotional numbness, or difficulties with trust and intimacy. These challenges can impact the dynamics of their romantic relationships.
What are 3 signs of PTSD?
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is characterized by a wide range of symptoms that can manifest in various ways, but here are three common signs often associated with PTSD:
- Intrusive thoughts and memories: Individuals with PTSD frequently experience intrusive and distressing thoughts, memories, or flashbacks related to the traumatic event(s). These thoughts can be vivid and unwanted, and they may intrude into daily life, causing emotional distress.
- Avoidance and numbing: People with PTSD may engage in avoidance behaviors to prevent exposure to reminders of the trauma. This can involve avoiding places, people, activities, or conversations that trigger distressing memories or emotions. Emotional numbing is also common, which can lead to difficulty experiencing positive emotions or feeling emotionally detached.
- Hyperarousal and reactivity: PTSD can lead to heightened levels of physiological and emotional arousal. Individuals may be easily startled, have difficulty sleeping (insomnia), and experience irritability and anger outbursts. They may also be hypervigilant, constantly on high alert for potential threats.
What age is most likely to develop PTSD?
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) can develop at any age, and the likelihood of developing PTSD is influenced by various factors, including the nature of the traumatic event, individual resilience, support and treatment. The lifetime prevalence of PTSD is around 6%, which means 6 out of 100 people will experience PTSD at some point during their life. Everyone may experience PTSD differently and, while there is no specific age group that is most likely to develop PTSD, certain life stages and experiences may increase the risk:
- Adolescents and young adults: Adolescents and young adults are susceptible to traumatic events such as accidents, violence, and sexual assault. The impact of trauma during these formative years can be significant and may lead to the development of PTSD.
- Military personnel: Military personnel, including young adults serving in the armed forces, may be exposed to combat trauma, which can increase the risk of PTSD. However, veterans of all ages can be affected.
- Children and adolescents: Traumatic experiences during childhood, such as physical or sexual abuse, neglect, or witnessing violence, can have long-lasting effects and increase the risk of developing PTSD later in life.
- Adults: Trauma can occur at any stage of adulthood, and individuals of all ages can be exposed to accidents, natural disasters, assaults, or other traumatic events.
- Elderly population: Older adults may experience trauma related to accidents, falls, medical procedures, or the loss of loved ones. Trauma in older adults can sometimes be overlooked or misattributed to age-related issues.
- First responders: Firefighters, police officers, and emergency medical personnel of various ages may experience trauma in the course of their work.
What does trauma do to a woman?
Trauma can have a profound impact on women, affecting their emotional, psychological, and physical well-being. Traumatic experiences can lead to conditions like post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), depression, and anxiety, with symptoms like intrusive thoughts, nightmares, and emotional numbing.
It's crucial to recognize that women's responses to trauma can vary, but with the right support and interventions, many can heal and recover, rebuilding their lives and well-being. Getting support from a therapist may help individuals experiencing PTSD to manage their symptoms and move forward. Therapies such as prolonged exposure therapy, talk therapy, or utilizing PTSD support groups may be good places to start.
What is the trauma of being a woman?
The concept of the "trauma of being a woman" refers to the unique and often pervasive challenges, discrimination, and injustices that women can face throughout their lives due to gender-based disparities and systemic inequalities. This type of trauma is not caused by a single traumatic event but rather by a series of gender-related experiences and societal factors that can have a cumulative and lasting impact on women's well-being. Some aspects of the trauma of being a woman include:
- Gender-based violence: Women are at a higher risk of experiencing various forms of gender-based violence, including domestic violence, sexual harassment, and sexual assault. These traumatic experiences can have long-lasting physical, emotional, and psychological effects.
- Discrimination and stereotyping: Women often face discrimination in various aspects of life, including the workplace, education, and healthcare. Stereotypes and gender biases can lead to feelings of inadequacy and the stress of constantly having to prove oneself.
- Sexual objectification: Objectification and sexualization of women's bodies in media and society can contribute to feelings of insecurity, body image issues, and low self-esteem.
- Reproductive health challenges: Women may experience traumatic events related to reproductive health, such as pregnancy complications, miscarriages, or difficulties getting reproductive healthcare.
- Gender pay gap: Economic disparities between genders, including the gender pay gap, can lead to financial stress, job insecurity, and limited opportunities for women.
- Inequities in healthcare: Gender-based inequities in healthcare and treatment can result in delayed or inadequate care, leading to worsened physical and mental health outcomes.
- Motherhood and work-life balance: Balancing motherhood with career responsibilities can be challenging, causing stress and emotional turmoil.
- Stereotypes and pressures: Societal expectations and stereotypes related to femininity and motherhood can be sources of distress and pressure on women.
Does PTSD ever go away?
The trajectory of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) varies widely among individuals. Some may naturally recover from their symptoms over time, while others may experience chronic or persistent symptoms. Effective treatments, such as trauma-focused therapies, can significantly improve the prognosis, but individual factors like the type and severity of trauma, coexisting mental health conditions, and social support play a crucial role in how PTSD progresses. Delayed-onset PTSD, where symptoms emerge months or years after trauma, is possible, emphasizing the need for ongoing monitoring and support. While PTSD symptoms may not completely disappear for everyone, many can learn to manage and cope with them, fostering resilience and personal growth. Early intervention and professional help remain essential for individuals dealing with PTSD.
How does a person with PTSD behave?
Individuals with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) may exhibit a range of behaviors and symptoms that can vary in severity and presentation. These behaviors are often linked to their efforts to cope with the distressing symptoms and memories associated with trauma. 10 common behaviors and signs of PTSD include:
- Avoidance: Avoidance behaviors are a hallmark of PTSD. Individuals may go to great lengths to avoid reminders of the traumatic event, which can include avoiding places, people, activities, or conversations that trigger distressing memories or emotions.
- Emotional numbing: People with PTSD may experience emotional numbing, which can manifest as a reduced ability to feel or express positive emotions, such as happiness or love. They may also have difficulty connecting with others on an emotional level.
- Irritability and anger: PTSD can lead to increased irritability and anger outbursts. Individuals may become easily frustrated or agitated, and minor stressors can trigger anger.
- Hypervigilance: Many individuals with PTSD are in a constant state of alertness and hypervigilance. They may be hyperaware of their surroundings, often scanning for potential threats.
- Startle response: A heightened startle response is common in PTSD. Individuals may react strongly to sudden noises, unexpected movements, or other stimuli, sometimes with panic or a fight-or-flight response.
- Flashbacks and intrusive thoughts: PTSD can result in intrusive thoughts, memories, or flashbacks related to the traumatic event. These can be vivid and distressing, making it challenging to concentrate on daily tasks.
- Sleep disturbances: Insomnia, frequent awakenings, and nightmares are common sleep disturbances in PTSD. Sleep problems can exacerbate other symptoms and lead to fatigue.
- Social withdrawal: People with PTSD may withdraw from social interactions and isolate themselves from friends and family due to feelings of shame, guilt, or a sense of being different from others.
- Substance abuse: Some individuals with PTSD may turn to alcohol abuse or drug abuse as a way to cope with their distressing symptoms, leading to substance abuse issues.
- Difficulty with trust and relationships: Trust issues can make it challenging to form and maintain healthy relationships. People with PTSD may struggle with vulnerability and intimacy.
- Previous Article
- Next Article