Inappropriate Affect Symptoms And Signs
While people may handle extreme situations and dramatic stimuli in a variety of unexpected ways, there are some who seem to have what are deemed "inappropriate" reactions to events. Not being able to effectively empathize or emotionally communicate with the world around you can be isolating and troubling and may only exacerbate the issues at the root of these concerns.
Inappropriate affect rarely occurs on its own, but instead is often a symptom of another underlying issue. If you or someone you care about is experiencing inappropriate affect, there are options for getting support and treatment. In this article, we’ll delve into what inappropriate affect is, why it manifests in some individuals, and where you can get help if you feel you or a loved one may be showing signs of it.
What is inappropriate affect?
Common examples of inappropriate affect include smiling at the news of a tragedy or remaining unemotional during a very emotional situation.
When mental health professionals are looking for insight into what may be causing one to manifest inappropriate affect, they’ll often look for past trauma or other psychological concerns. Inappropriate affect is usually a sign of a deeper psychological or physical health condition such as schizoid personality disorder, Autism, dementia, Alzheimer's disease, brain tumors, PTSD, depression, or some form of brain damage. Areas of the brain that are typically examined include the limbic system, anterior cingulate cortex, brainstem, and prefrontal cortex. Tests are also normally done to rule out any neurological conditions.
If you are experiencing trauma, support is available. Please see our Get Help Now page for more resources.
While inappropriate affect is a symptom itself, it can manifest in different ways depending on the individual. Emotional expression varies among individuals and cultures, and inappropriate expressions can be defined or justified in a myriad of ways. Understanding the signs of inappropriate affect can help you to determine if you or someone you love has this condition. However, it can be important to avoid making a diagnosis on your own and instead consult a medical professional.
While the expression of emotion varies among people, there are basic human signs of happiness, anger, love, and sadness that transcend individual circumstances. For those with inappropriate affect, the emotions they express often do not accurately represent the reality of an event. This might be expressed in countless ways, but some situations are clearer indicators than others.
The following are some major signs of inappropriate affect:
- Expressing emotions that do not fit reality
- Abnormal emotional responses
- Depression, irritability, or outbursts of anger without an obvious cause
- Manic episodes
Note that the disconnect from reality can vary from slight to severe and that each of these other symptoms can also be more or less extreme, depending on the person.
Arriving at a diagnosis
Being officially diagnosed with inappropriate affect requires the skills of a licensed mental health professional. A psychologist or psychiatrist will examine the signs of inappropriate affect to try and diagnose the underlying condition or mental health disorder. Depending on which part of the brain is being affected, the severity of the inappropriateness of one's emotions can vary.
Typically, a mental status examination (MSE) is used by clinicians to examine the mood and affect of an individual and whether it is congruent to reality. The MSE will help the clinician make a diagnosis as to the mental stability of the individual. If an individual's mood and affect are thought to be inappropriate, then further examinations will be done to uncover the underlying reason. For most, inappropriate affect is rarely a diagnosis that stands alone.
An example of this process would be using inappropriate affect to uncover a deeper schizoaffective disorder. Those with schizoaffective disorder tend to have hallucinations and delusions, and the emotions displayed during episodes are not based in reality. The resulting manifestation of inappropriate affect points to a schizoaffective issue, allowing it to now be more effectively treated.
In rare cases, inappropriate affect occurs with no underlying mental or physical condition behind it. Without a catalyst, it is known as inappropriate affect syndrome.
Professionals might also consider the pseudobulbar affect when someone is displaying signs of inappropriate affect. Those with pseudobulbar affect still display inappropriate emotions but are aware that they are doing so.
Treatment options
Since those with inappropriate affect can sometimes have a problem accurately grasping reality, conversation and talk therapy may be difficult. This can make treatment solutions outside of medication challenging. Research is ongoing and new medications for these disorders and symptoms are being developed, discovered, and improved.
As research into the causes and effects of inappropriate affect progresses, so will the efficacy of treatment methods. Some of the current treatment options available for those displaying symptoms of inappropriate affect include the following.
Speaking with a licensed professional
The treatment required to alleviate inappropriate affect typically depends on the underlying mental or physical disorder causing the symptoms. In many cases, finding and connecting with a licensed mental health professional can be one of the first steps to getting treatment for yourself or someone you love. The effectiveness of any treatment for a disorder like this relies on observation and feedback. It can be vital to find a therapist you trust and can be fully honest with.
Pursue treatment for underlying issues
Most disorders that have symptoms like inappropriate affect are likely to be treated with diagnosis-dependent medications. This explains why seeking out help from a professional can be important. For example, schizoaffective disorders and schizoid personality disorders are two very common causes of inappropriate affect and both require specific medication to effectively control symptoms. Therapy is also often used along with medications to lessen the severity of symptoms.
Reduce daily stress and practice emotional control
Some research has shown that a reduction in daily stress and improvement in emotional control can help delay the onset of symptoms of certain physical and mental illnesses and symptoms. Family and friends can play an active role in learning how to interact with those living with inappropriate affect, lessening stress levels on both parties. Since those with the disorder are not willfully upsetting others, negative reactions may only exacerbate the issue. Loved ones who are willing to be patient and empathetic can make a powerful difference in the lives of those living with inappropriate affect.
Online therapy for emotional control
Even if you have already met with a medical professional, processing your diagnosis and approaching the challenges of daily life might feel stressful and overwhelming. Many people find that they need the added help of a counselor who can help guide them and listen to their concerns.
If you’re experiencing concerns about emotional control, speaking with a therapist could be useful. However, it may be intimidating to discuss sensitive topics and emotions with a therapist face-to-face. With online therapy platforms like BetterHelp, you can participate in counseling via live chat, videoconferencing, voice call, or messaging. The comfort offered by online therapy may make it the right option for you.
Online therapy's effectiveness
Studies show that online therapy can be an effective form of treatment to help those experiencing inappropriate affect to manage their symptoms. In a study published in the Journal of Medical Internet Research, the effects of online cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) on emotion control were examined. Researchers found that the intervention was superior to treatment as usual on measures of depression, anxiety, and health-related quality of life. CBT is a widely accepted method of therapy that works by helping individuals reframe negative thought patterns that may be underlying unhealthy emotions or behaviors, such as symptoms of inappropriate affect.
Below you can read some reviews of BetterHelp counselors from people who have found support with similar challenges.
Counselor reviews
"Gina has been extremely helpful. With her help, I have been able to get back to my better self and see what was getting in the way. I am working on tools and ways to break through and be happier and more emotionally stable with her. Thanks Gina!"
"Jamie has helped me so much during a tough time. She is quick to respond and responds with great questions and knowledge that helped me grasp my emotions and the situations I was in. I have seen improvement in just a few weeks, thanks to her. I'm still working on things, but she's always there, even checking in when I haven't responded in a few days. She never made me feel pressured to reply but rather touched that she just wanted to check in that I was doing ok. She is so kind and has complimented my progress in a way that makes me feel so empowered. I strongly recommend her. Jamie, you're too awesome! Thanks for everything!"
Takeaway
What causes inappropriate affect?
Brain damage or dysfunction is one potential cause for inappropriate affect. This may include damage from head trauma, brain injury, tumor, and neurological disorders like dementia.
Conditions like borderline personality disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder may cause inappropriate affect. So can mood disorders like major depressive and bipolar disorder, as well as schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, and other psychotic disorders.
Some medications for psychological conditions may influence how individuals experience emotions, potentially facilitating inappropriate affect symptoms. For example, a 2016 study in the International Journal of Bipolar Disorders revealed that some medications like mood stabilizers, antipsychotics, and certain antidepressants used to treat schizophrenia and psychotic disorders caused emotional blunting and an inability to cry in situations where those emotional responses would be appropriate.
What is an example of an appropriate affect?
Appropriate affect refers to an individual's expected and fitting emotional reaction to a situation. Examples include crying at a funeral or laughing at a funny joke.
What is the difference between labile affect and inappropriate affect?
Labile affect is a type of inappropriate affect characterized by rapid, repeating changes in emotion that are out of proportion to the circumstances. People with labile affect may seem like their emotions are out of control.
Inappropriate affect is when the emotional reaction doesn't match the circumstances but isn't as "frenzied" as labile affect. It doesn't seem as out of control or change as rapidly.
What are the four types of affect?
While mood refers to the more stable, consistent emotions of an individual's personality, affect is how an individual shows their feelings in the moment. The four types of affect include:
- Broad Or Full Affect—Refers to the typical and expected expression of emotions in response to specific scenarios. For example, if an employee receives a raise for excellent performance, that individual would typically react with satisfaction and happiness.
- Restricted Affect— An unusually diminished or constricted emotional response to a situation that would typically elicit a significant emotional reaction. For example, if an individual wins the lottery and seems mildly pleased but not elated as would be typical and expected, they may have restricted affect.
- Labile Affect— Refers to inappropriate emotional reactions that change rapidly and erratically.
- Flat Or Blunted Affect— An individual with blunted affect shows very little emotion, and flat affect expresses no emotion in response to emotionally charged circumstances. A person with flat affect may not express fear when confronted with a frightening situation such as being mugged.
What is the difference between appropriate and inappropriate affect?
Appropriate affect is the standard and expected expression of emotion fitting to the circumstance. A person displays appropriate affect if they are sad upon hearing about a friend's or loved one's death.
Inappropriate affect refers to a person's inability to react in a typical way when faced with emotionally charged situations. A person with inappropriate affect may laugh upon hearing about the death of a loved one.
Is inappropriate affect a positive or negative symptom?
In the past, inappropriate affect was typically considered a "negative" symptom (referring to an absence or reduction of normal behaviors, not to be confused with negative emotions), but recent research has uncovered aspects of the symptom that indicate a "positive" label (an addition of abnormal behaviors) may be more appropriate. Types of inappropriate affect, such as flat and restricted affect, are still categorized as negative symptoms.
What is euthymic affect?
While euthymic affect can describe a normal, content emotional state in any circumstance, it's most associated with the emotional functioning that may occur between the hallmark manic/depressive/mixed episodes of bipolar disorder.
Clinicians use the presence of euthymic affect to recognize the onset of mood episodes. The absence of euthymic affect between episodes may indicate another condition, such as attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).
What are the three forms of affect?
While affect types describe an individual's outer expression of emotional response, the three forms (or dimensions) of affect describe the experience of feeling emotions. These include:
- Valence— Labels an affect as positive, negative, or at some point in between.
- Arousal— Describes the intensity level of the emotion.
- Motivational Intensity— Refers to the emotional intensity required to create an aversion to an emotional stimulus.
What are the five descriptors of affect?
When psychologists conduct a Mental Status Exam (MSE) to assess a patient, they note many details such as speech, appearance and behavior, cognition, and psychological factors. One of the most integral parts of this initial process is the investigation of mood and affect.
While the mental health professional relies on the patient's verbal communication to determine mood, they can objectively observe affect using five descriptors:
- Appropriateness of the patient's affect in relation to their current circumstances.
- Fluctuations in the patient's affect. For example, do they express labile affect? Does the affect appear stable and euthymic?
- Range of affect observed in the patient. These may include broad or full and diminished or restricted.
- The patient's affect intensity. Does the patient's outward expression of emotion seem flat or blunted? Is it inappropriately dramatic or energized?
- The patient's quality of affect. These refer to the descriptors one may use to label affect, including detached, anxious, irritable, elated, sad, hostile, etc.
*Note: Assessments like the MSE should be administered by qualified mental health professionals with a specialized advanced degree such as a Ph.D. or master's degree in psychology. If you think you may have symptoms of inappropriate affect, seek professional help from a mental healthcare provider for an accurate diagnosis.
What is blunted inappropriate affect?
This type of inappropriate affect is characterized by a decreased ability or inability to express emotions outwardly through tone of voice, facial expressions, and body language.
- Previous Article
- Next Article