Understanding Serial Monogamy
Updated April 29, 2020
Reviewer Kay Adkins, LPC
While many of your friends have been out having a good time, casually dating as many people as possible before they settle down, have you always been in long-term relationship after long-term relationship? If so, then you may be a serial monogamist, or you may be a serial dater. We can help explain the difference.
Serial Monogamist versus Serial Dater
The main difference is that a serial monogamist always wants to be in a relationship. If someone breaks up with you, do you go insane until you can be in another relationship again? Or, if you're the one to do the dumping, do you make sure you have someone lined up first before you break up with your current partner, so that you will never have to be single? If so, then this is the classic definition of a serial monogamist. Taylor Swift is a popular example of a serial monogamist.
A serial dater, on the other hand, is quite the opposite and runs far away from commitment. The serial dater is more likely to be dating several people at the same time, so as not to be tied down to any one person. Furthermore, the people he or she is dating understand that it's nothing serious, that the serial dater is just going out to have fun and has no intention of settling down anytime soon - the "player" if you will.
Signs That You May Be A Serial Monogamist
A serial monogamist, as mentioned above, is always in a relationship. If your friends in high school teased you that you were already married because you've been with your boyfriend or girlfriend for so long, and then teased you about the same thing with the next person, then you may be a serial monogamist. This means being single makes you feel uncomfortable, and you can probably count on one hand the number of months you have ever been single in your dating life.
Serial monogamists are also guilty of talking about their exes, even when they're in a relationship with someone new. The reason for this is due to the relationships overlapping or happening within a short span of each other; you may not be giving yourself enough time to get over your ex before jumping headfirst into a new relationship. Everyone tells you that you shouldn't talk to your current partner about your former partner, but you find that you just can't help yourself.
Another sign you may be a serial monogamist is if you feel extremely awkward attending social events without a partner. If you don't have a girlfriend or boyfriend and you're invited to an event, you'd opt out of it, rather than face everyone alone. This makes sense, considering the reason why you may be a serial monogamist in the first place is that you detest the idea of being alone.
You also may be a serial monogamist if you find it absolutely impossible to have casual sex without it turning into something more. You'd much rather wake up to your partner making you breakfast and reading the paper to each other at the kitchen table than wake up alone after a night of fiery lovemaking, You're more about the emotional connection, rather than the physical one. You may not even be able to see yourself enjoying a one-night stand.
Things To Know About Dating A Serial Monogamist
What happens if you're not the serial monogamist, but you find yourself dating someone who is? How do you prepare for that level of commitment right from the start? Well, you don't have to worry just yet about your partner getting down on one knee or planning names for the children you two will have together. There are a lot of benefits to dating a serial monogamist, rather than someone who enjoys playing the field.
Serial monogamists may sound like stage-5 clingers, but the reality is that they know exactly what can cause a relationship to end, and they refrain from doing those things. Serial monogamists tend to be more mature when it comes to dating, so they recognize when you need space and when things need to cool off a little before they take the next step.
You may find the experience of dating a serial monogamist to be a relief from the kind of people you used to date. For one thing, a serial monogamist is not ready to throw in the towel just because you fought over something minor. Yelling at him over leaving the toilet seat up for the hundredth time is not going to cause him to pack up his stuff and walk out. You may find yourself saying that now you're dating a "real" man or a "real" woman.
Another thing about them is that a serial monogamist is more intent on making sure that you're happy. That means that when it comes time for gifts, whether it's Valentine's Day or your anniversary, you're not going to get the same thing that everyone else is getting because it's "easier." The serial monogamist will go out of his or her way to get you something customized or personalized, something with meaning that you will treasure for years- rather than flowers that die or chocolate that goes stale.
And guess what "making sure you're happy" extends to? That's right - sex. A serial monogamist may not have had as many relationships as his or her "player" friends, yet s/he may be even better in the bedroom than those friends. Why? Because your partner takes the time to learn what makes you tick and will do exactly what you want and need to keep you happy.
How Do You Know If Your Partner Is A Serial Dater?
Maybe you're back on the dating scene with the intention of finding a serial monogamist because you've had enough of serial daters. How would you be able to tell right off the bat that someone is a serial dater, so you can know before you get too involved?
For one thing, because serial daters want to do as much of that - serial dating - as possible, they may be incredibly impatient to take you out on that first date. A serial dater won't care that they don't know much about you before trying to whisk you away. And you'll know they won't know enough about you yet because you'll also barely know anything about them.
Charm is another thing to be careful of. If someone is an expert at being charming, it may be because they've had plenty of practice at it. When someone is trying to date as many people as possible, then s/he learns the finer points of being charming to get as many people to fall for them as possible. It may work on you too, and that's okay, so long as you recognize it for what it is and can walk away if it's not what you want.
Serial daters also avoid getting into anything too heavy - this includes meaningful conversation. If you find that all you talk about on your first date are shallow topics and that there isn't even a hint of anything that could be probed deeper to learn more about that person, then s/he is probably keeping you at arms-length for a reason. If they don't ask you any in-depth questions either, then this is a sure sign that they are not interested in getting to know you as a person; they are more interested in living in the moment and having fun.
If s/he also focuses more on how you look, rather than admit how they truly feel about you, then this may be another sign that they are a serial dater. If someone feels strongly for you, it's not something they can just shut off. The reality is that they are trying to not fall deeply for you because for them it's not about commitment; expressing their feelings for you is certainly one of the first signs of forging a deeper commitment.
Letting A Serial Dater Go
You may find it difficult to say goodbye to a serial dater. One of the most common reasons for this difficulty is because the sex is just too good. But of course, it would be. When you focus on the physical aspects of the relationship, then you don't have to delve too deep into anything else about it.
If you're fine with keeping your relationship physical until you tire of each other, that's one thing. But if you want something more than just the casual hook-up once a week, then you may want to consider moving on.
You can have sex that is just as fantastic - maybe even better - with a serial monogamist, who truly cares about seeing to your needs and making you happy. Plus, you get all of the benefits that come from being with someone who wants to learn everything they can about you and solidify the foundation for what could be an enriching and wonderful future with you- whether it ends in a committed relationship or not.
Difficulties of Serial Dating or Monogamy
Whether you are a serial monogamist, a serial dater, or in a relationship with one type or the other, we are not here to judge. Everybody has different wants, needs, and expectations from a relationship. Both types have their advantages, which may be suitable for you.
However, at the same time, both styles can have their disadvantages. A serial monogamist may have never learned the values of independence, while the serial dater may have never experienced a committed relationship. Both of these are important aspects of life.
On the other side, you may be dating a serial monogamist/dater. Perhaps you are having difficulty with communicating space with a serial monogamist, or maybe you are heart broken that your serial dater partner will not settle down to a committed relationship. If you are having difficulty on either side of serial dating or serial monogamy, help is right around the corner.
Consider Talking with Someone
BetterHelp is here to listen, discuss, and help you make progress on a variety of relationship issues. Consider talking to someone about what might be troubling you, including the hangups of serial monogamy and serial dating. BetterHelp is an affordable, convenient, and professional e-counseling website that can help you work through any issues by matching you with a licensed therapist. Below are some counselor reviews, from people experiencing similar relationship issues.
"Andrea has been nothing short of wonderful since I started counseling with her. She always makes me feel heard and validated, while at the same time challenging me to question the way I think about and react to different situations. She is thoughtful, caring, and nonjudgmental. I have seen a huge difference in myself, my relationships, and my happiness since I started working with her."
"Dr. Ciraky has proven to be an excellent sounding board and has provided tools to work through my relationship issues. He has been insightful and given me things to think about to direct me in my decision-making process. I would highly recommend him."
Both serial monogamy and serial dating aren't inherent problems. But if bad habits are creeping up, from a lack of intimacy, self respect, or individual identity, it may be time to reach out for assistance. Take the first step to fulfilling relationships today.