For many, traumatic memories can be a source of stress, life challenges, and even mental health conditions. Many types of therapy are available to help those who have experienced past trauma. One such therapeutic approach is repressed memory therapy, sometimes called recovered memory therapy. This form of counseling targets the subconscious, cognitive processing, and traumatic events and memories that people may not be aware of. Repressed memories and therapy for repressed memories are controversial topics that experts continually debate. Before choosing any type of therapy, research the current statistics on treatment and make an informed decision.
Recommended Change: Defining Repressed Memories: What Exactly Are They?
Repressed memories are said to be the result of challenging experiences or traumatic experiences that are difficult for the mind to process, resulting in lost memories. In some cases, a repressed memory may be from childhood trauma or childhood abuse. In others, an individual might experience symptoms from a traumatic event. A repressed memory may feel blurry or unclear, or a person may not remember the event at all. These “forgotten memories” are known as repressed memories and are commonly seen in post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD).
Are Repressed Memories Real?
Repressed memories have been a subject of debate in psychology since some of the first psychologists developed psychotherapy. Some researchers don’t believe it’s possible for people to repress memories. On the other hand, some mental health professionals claim to have worked with clients experiencing memory repression. Some believe people repress memories as a defense mechanism against difficult feelings that the memory would evoke; others do not believe this theory. This debate is often referred to as the "memory wars."
A research study published in Psychological Science showed a clear divide between clinicians and researchers on the topic. According to the study, around 60% to 80% of therapists, clinicians, and psychoanalysts who responded to the survey agreed that traumatic memories could be repressed and retrieved in therapy. In comparison, less than 30% of research-oriented psychologists believed it.
Some researchers may have concerns about how the mind would be stimulated to recover a repressed memory. On the other hand, some therapists may have anecdotal evidence they have gained from their experience with clients not backed by peer-reviewed studies and concrete results.
Additionally, repressed memories encountered in therapy may be difficult or impossible to prove afterward. According to the American Psychological Association, experienced clinical psychologists state that the phenomenon of recovered memory is rare.
It’s important to note that repressed memories are different from other mental health conditions like bipolar disorder and dissociative amnesia, which can both involve lapses in memory.
Why Would You Want To Recover Repressed Memories?
Some people may wonder why someone would want to recover repressed memories if they were painful or traumatic. Mental health professionals offering recovered memory therapy typically believe that mental health issues, phobias, and challenging symptoms might result from repressed memories of past trauma. By exploring a recovered memory through repressed memory therapy, they believe that people may better understand the origins of their mental health challenges.
For example, a person may recover a traumatic memory of child abuse during the course of therapy. By discussing this recovered memory, they may better understand the mental health challenges, feelings, and relationships they experience as adults.
A 2021 study shows that repressed memories may not exist. However, there could be other causes for this phenomenon, such as forgetting a traumatic memory or misinterpreting a previous memory as a traumatic event even if it was not. People may remember these events without trying or recover them through therapy like trauma counseling. It may not be a conscious effort to remember the traumatic event in all cases. At times, a false memory may arise when attempting to recover repressed memories.
Repressed Memory Therapy: How It Began And What It Is Today
Some individuals may seek out repressed memory counseling because they believe they have repressed memories impacting their lives. Despite the ongoing debate around this type of therapy, some therapists or counselors may try an approach like hypnosis, guided imagery, or age regression therapy. They might also try a traditional approach to steer conversations toward memory.
History Of Repressed Memories And The Subconscious Mind
The first psychologist to bring the idea of repressed memories into the mainstream was Sigmund Freud. Freud regularly worked with theories surrounding the subconscious, particularly concerning childhood trauma and forgotten or repressed memories.
As a result, discovering the subconscious elements that caused a person to think, feel, or behave unwantedly was a focus of Freud's treatment.
One of the ways that Freud and others in his time would try the subconscious was through hypnotism. However, over time, he stopped using it in his practice. Some therapists still use hypnosis today, but it is not as popular as in Freud's time.
Many argue that memories that were supposedly suppressed were memories of childhood that the individual was aware of but avoiding rather than repressing. This avoidance may have been due to discomfort, anxious feelings, abuse, fear of reprisal from a family, or a negative impact on their life.
If you are facing or witnessing abuse of any kind, the National Domestic Violence Hotline is available 24/7 for support. Call 1-800-799-SAFE (7233) or text "START" to 88788. You can also use the online chat.
Recent Significance Of Repressed Memories
After Freud’s time, the practice of memory therapy again became popular in the 1980s and '90s with cases of abuse, including sexual abuse. Some repressed memory stories ended up in court, and the repressed memories led to convictions. In other cases, however, the repressed memories were found to be examples of false memory. Some scientists suggested that the therapists had planted the memories while the client was in an altered state of consciousness, or the clients' brains conjured false memories of the traumatic events that seemed genuine.
Some believed this was an accident, while others believed the therapists had deliberately suggested false memories for the clients to recover. They believed that sensitive clients were more susceptible to believing the trauma that a therapist suggested about their memories. Further, as repressed memory theories grew in popularity, cases of false memories became more common. People began to report alien abductions and other potentially unlikely events. Gradually, the credibility of this therapy faded away within the psychological community.
Asking For Help: Counseling Options
Repressed memories continue to be actively debated. Researchers may not be sure if specific experiences can be remembered through memory therapy techniques such as guided imagery. Because it is not grounded in medically reviewed scientific evidence as other forms of treatment like cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT), repressed memory treatment may not be a popular first choice for treatment. However, there are many other types of therapy available.
A licensed therapist may help you cope with past trauma or distressing symptoms using evidence-based methods targeting abuse and trauma through talk therapy and cognitive processing. For some individuals living with trauma or painful memories, discussing such personal topics may feel challenging and vulnerable in person. Speaking with a professional in a space where you feel comfortable and at ease may be helpful. In these cases, people may opt for online therapy. With online therapy through a platform like BetterHelp, you can find a therapist from any location with a solid internet connection. Research has shown that online therapy can be an effective treatment option for individuals experiencing the effects of trauma.
For instance, one study examined the effectiveness of an internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy program for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). The study found that the individuals who received treatment experienced significant improvements in symptom severity, allowing researchers to conclude that internet-based therapy proved a viable treatment alternative for PTSD with large effect sizes and sustained treatment effects.
Why Choose BetterHelp: BetterHelp Therapist Review
“I have appreciated my subscription to BetterHelp and have recommended it to a couple of friends. My therapist helped me get through a really difficult time. It was such a relief knowing she would respond immediately when I needed support. And even when our conversations were difficult, she always pulled me through. I have more confidence in my ability to refute anxiety and face it, rather than avoid and give power to old memories. Thanks, B”
There is an ongoing debate around repressed memories and repressed memory therapy, but it may be an interesting topic to explore. Ensure you do research before partaking in any form of therapy, and only work with a licensed and experienced counselor. If you are living with trauma or challenging memories that you would like support with, consider reaching out to a counselor through an online platform or within your area for further guidance and support.
What is the treatment for repressed memory?
The treatment of repressed memories, particularly those associated with traumatic experiences, typically involves specialized therapeutic approaches. These therapies are designed to safely and effectively help individuals recall and process these memories, with the goal of reducing their psychological impact.
- Trauma-focused psychotherapy: This form of therapy is specifically designed to address the unique issues related to trauma. Trauma-focused psychotherapy often involves helping individuals confront and reprocess traumatic memories in a controlled and safe environment. The therapist guides the individual through the process of recalling the traumatic event and helps them to understand and contextualize their experiences. This approach aims to diminish the power of the repressed memories over the individual's emotional well-being.
- Exposure techniques: Exposure therapy is a technique within cognitive-behavioral therapy that involves gradual exposure to the trauma memory in a safe setting. The idea is to reduce the fear and distress associated with the memory, thereby diminishing its impact. Exposure is done under the guidance of a therapist, who ensures that the process is performed in a controlled manner to prevent re-traumatization.
- Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR): EMDR is a relatively new but increasingly popular therapy for trauma and PTSD. The treatment involves the individual focusing on traumatic memories while simultaneously engaging in bilateral stimulation (typically eye movements). This process is believed to facilitate the brain's natural healing processes. EMDR can help individuals process and integrate traumatic memories, reducing their ongoing impact.
Individuals should approach the treatment of repressed memories with care, as improperly handled interventions can lead to further psychological harm. The therapeutic process should be paced and tailored to the individual's specific needs and readiness to confront difficult memories. Working with a qualified mental health professional who specializes in trauma is crucial for ensuring safe and effective treatment.
Can therapy recover repressed memories?
While therapy can help individuals recall and process repressed memories, it is important to note that the accuracy of these memories may be difficult to verify. Repressed memories are often highly subjective and may be influenced by emotions, suggestibility, or other cognitive biases. Additionally, research suggests that trauma can impact memory itself, leading to fragmented or distorted recollections.
False memories may also occur during the therapeutic process, where an individual may remember events that never actually occurred. Therefore, it is important for individuals to work with a trained therapist who understands the complexities of repressed memories and can guide them through the therapy process in a safe and responsible manner.
Through therapy, individuals may be able to gain a better understanding of their past experiences and how they may have affected their current psychological well-being. So, while repressed memories may be uncovered, it is ultimately up to the individual and their therapist to determine how these memories are processed and integrated into their overall healing journey.
Regardless of the outcome, therapy can provide a supportive and accepting space for individuals to explore and address repressed memories in a way that promotes healing and growth. It is not a quick fix, but with patience and diligence, therapy can help individuals find peace and closure with their past experiences.
Is repressed memory therapy real?
Despite some controversy and skepticism around the concept of repressed memories, there is evidence to support their existence. Many individuals have reported experiencing repressed memories, and research has shown that trauma can impact memory in various ways. However, it is important to note that the validity of specific repressed memories may be difficult to verify.
In terms of therapy for repressed memories, while there is no one-size-fits-all approach, many trained professionals have successfully helped individuals recall and process these memories in a safe and effective manner. The key is to work with a qualified therapist who has experience and expertise in this area.
No matter what someone's experiences may be, it's important for them to know they are not alone and that support is available. Therapy can provide resources and a framework for individuals to safely explore and make sense of their experiences. Therapy can also offer tools and coping mechanisms for managing any psychological impacts these memories may have.
How can I recover repressed memories on my own?
Recovering repressed memories without professional guidance can be risky and potentially harmful. It is recommended to work with a trained therapist who specializes in trauma and has experience working with repressed memories.
However, there are some self-care practices individuals can engage in to help them cope with the potential psychological effects of repressed memories. These may include:
- Mindfulness techniques: Practicing mindfulness can help individuals stay grounded in the present moment and manage any overwhelming or distressing thoughts.
- Journaling: Writing down thoughts, feelings, and experiences can help individuals process and make sense of their emotions and memories in a safe space.
- Seeking support: Connecting with loved ones, joining support groups, or seeking therapy can provide a sense of validation, understanding, and companionship.
It is important for individuals to prioritize self-care and seek support if they are experiencing repressed memories. Working through these difficult experiences can be challenging, but you may find healing and peace with the help of therapy and self-care practices.
How do I know if I am repressing memories?
Dissociative amnesia, or repressed memories, can be difficult to identify as it is a coping mechanism to protect oneself from traumatic events. However, some signs that an individual may be repressing memories include:
- Experiencing unexplained anxiety, fear, or distress: Memories can resurface in the form of intense emotions and sensations.
- Having gaps in your memory: Individuals may have difficulty remembering significant events or details from their past.
- Feeling disconnected from one's emotions: Repressed memories can manifest as a disconnection from one's feelings and experiences, resulting in emotional numbness.
- Experiencing odd or unexplained physical sensations: Some individuals may experience physical symptoms such as headaches, nausea, or muscle tension without any clear cause.
If you are experiencing any of these symptoms, it is important to seek support from a mental health professional who can help you explore and address any potential repressed memories in a safe and responsible manner. Remember, healing from trauma takes time and patience, but with the right support, you can begin to process and make sense of your experiences.
Should I try to recover repressed memories?
The decision to try and recover repressed memories should not be taken lightly. It is a highly personal and individual choice that should only be made with the guidance of a trained therapist.
Some individuals may feel that recovering repressed memories will provide closure or healing, while others may fear the potential emotional impact of recalling traumatic events. It is important to consider your own readiness for exploring these memories and to prioritize your well-being above all else.
It's also important to keep in mind that therapy for repressed memories does not guarantee the recovery of specific memories. The focus should be on healing and processing past experiences rather than solely trying to recall them.
Recovery is not a journey you should take alone, and it's important to seek support from a trained professional if you are considering trying to recover repressed memories. They can provide a safe and compassionate space for you to explore your experiences at your own pace and ensure that your safety and well-being are prioritized throughout the process.
What can trigger a repressed memory?
Repressed memories can be triggered by various factors, but they are often associated with a traumatic event or experience. Some common triggers for repressed memories may include:
- Exposure to reminders: Certain sights, sounds, smells, or other sensory stimuli that are associated with past traumas can trigger the recall of repressed memories.
- Anniversaries or significant dates: Birthdays, holidays, or other important dates that are associated with past traumas can bring back repressed memories.
- Experiencing a similar event: In some cases, individuals may repress memories of one traumatic event and then experience a similar trauma later in life, causing the original memory to resurface.
Triggers for repressed memories can be unpredictable and unexpected, making it crucial to have support in place if you are working through repressed memories. As you learn to manage these triggers, you may find that their impact lessens over time. Patience and self-compassion are key as you navigate this difficult journey.
Can repressed memories never come back?
There is no guarantee that repressed memories will never resurface, even after seeking therapy and processing past experiences. However, with the help of a trained therapist, individuals can learn coping mechanisms and tools for managing any potential triggers or distressing emotions that may arise.
Repressed memories are also not always accurate or reliable. Memories can be influenced by external factors such as suggestion or imagination, and it is important to approach any recovered memories with a critical and cautious mindset.
Healing from trauma does not mean that all memories will be neatly resolved or recalled. Recovery is a fluid and ongoing process that involves finding ways to cope and move forward while acknowledging the impact of past experiences. Through proactive self-care practices and trained professional support, individuals can learn to manage the impact of repressed memories and find ways to live a fulfilling and meaningful life.
What happens to a memory when it is repressed?
When memory is repressed, it is unconsciously pushed out of a person's immediate awareness as a defense mechanism against psychological distress. Repression is a concept originally proposed in Freudian psychoanalytic theory, suggesting that individuals protect themselves from painful or traumatic memories by moving them from conscious to unconscious thought.
Memories are not stored in the brain as static entities but are dynamically encoded and stored across various neural networks. When a memory is formed, it involves a complex process of encoding, storage, and retrieval orchestrated by different parts of the brain, primarily the hippocampus, amygdala, and prefrontal cortex.
In the case of traumatic or distressing memories, the brain sometimes engages in repression as a way to manage emotional overload or trauma. The process involves the amygdala, which plays a crucial role in processing emotions, and the prefrontal cortex, which is involved in decision-making and moderating social behavior. The interaction between these regions can lead to the involuntary suppression of memories that are too overwhelming to handle consciously.
Repressed memories still exist in the brain but are not readily accessible or consciously retrievable. They might be triggered unintentionally by specific cues or stimuli related to the original event, often manifesting as flashbacks or physical responses. The concept of repressed memories is still a subject of considerable debate in psychology, with some researchers questioning the validity and mechanisms behind memory repression.
While the brain has mechanisms to manage overwhelming or traumatic memories, sometimes these memories resurface later in life. If you are experiencing distressing memories, seeking support from a therapist can help you safely process and work through these experiences to find healing and closure.
- Previous Article
- Next Article