The Psychology Of False Memory: Causes and Features Of False Memories
In general, false memories are memories a person holds that are inaccurate or did not actually happen. Although we generally tend to trust our memories, it can be common to have false memories. For example, hearing incorrect information repeatedly can result in a false memory. Inaccurate perceptions or interpretations of situations can also contribute to false memories. Older people may be especially prone to false recollections. If you’re concerned about your own memories or perceptions, speaking with a licensed therapist may be helpful. You can connect with a mental health professional online or in person.
Understanding false memory
Memories may be more complex entities than we can fully understand. Our brains are a vast system of complex neural connections, and our experiences can be prone to sensory misinterpretation, memory distortions, and cognitive bias.
How false memories are created
There may be a variety of causes and situations that can lead to false memories. These false recollections can be dangerous and traumatic to the individual who experiences them, especially if they are unaware that the memories are not real.
Suggestion and leading questions
Suggestibility can be a common cause of false memories, especially when a person is subjected to leading questions from an authority figure. This can happen during criminal cases, when a lawyer “leads the witness”, or when law enforcement officers try to have a witness identify a person of interest in a crime.
Misinformation effect
Another cause of false memories can be misinformation, a problem that has become even more prevalent due to the increase in social media content, AI, and “news” that comes from dubious sources. Hearing a false story several times, especially from a person that you trust, can cause your brain to accept the story as true.
Cognitive biases and schemas
Cognitive biases are ways in which we color the information that we receive based on our schemas, the way in which we understand and interact with the world. Many people remember events through the lens of these biases without realizing that this is what they’re doing.
Trauma, stress, and emotional abuse
Memory mistakes can happen as a result of traumatic experiences or times of intense emotional stress. How the brain processes information can be impacted as our nervous system reacts to the situation. The stress hormone cortisol can impact memory processing, and the emotions surrounding the event can lead to the individual ruminating on it, adding distortions as they replay it.
The presence of certain mental health conditions
Psychology researchers have also found that false memory or memory mistakes may be attributed to overthinking and rumination. Individuals with anxiety, depression, OCD, or PTSD may be more prone to this increased emotional processing and experience memory distortions as a result.
30,000+ therapists with diverse specialties
Impacts of aging on false memory
Another challenge can be the aging process. As we get older, we can become more susceptible to false memories as we rely more on what are called schematic memories. As the name implies, these memories are based more on the substance or essence of a certain event, rather than the event itself.
Other factors that may be involved
There are other factors that may be responsible for or contribute to false memories. These can include:
- Being under the influence of drugs or alcohol
- Sleep deprivation
- Memory interference
- Social pressure
Neurological and cognitive factors in false memory
Scientists have studied the brain activity and processes that may be responsible for memory distortions. Brain processes are extremely complicated, but emerging neuroimaging technology and advances in neuropsychological testing have made it possible to get some idea of how false memories can form.
Brain regions involved
The parts of the brain that are involved in creating false memories include:
- Hippocampus. Responsible for reconstructing memory and memory retrieval, this area can combine real and imagined details
- Prefrontal cortex. Reduced activity in this area, which is responsible for validating memories can lead to errors
- Amygdala. The seat of intense emotion and threat detection, this area can be responsible for enhancing the vividness of highly emotional fabricated events
Memory reconsolidation and neuroplasticity
The brain can be subject to misinterpretation of situations, and imagination can distort and color events. Emotions may also contribute. Neuroplasticity is the brain’s ability to reorganize and form new neural connections. Helpful for learning, neuroplasticity means that memory is not a fixed recording, but is subject to reconsolidation.
fMRI and experimental evidence of false memories
This emerging information on the sources of false memory has been made possible by fMRI imaging. Scientists use this process to target which areas of the brain are involved in the creation of false memories, and this imaging can also show the difference between intentional lying and misremembering a situation.
Why do people believe false information?
Various individuals may internalize false information because doing so is often easier than taking the time to evaluate and assess what they're being told.
Therefore, the human brain often routinely defaults to the newly processed false information instead of taking time to dig deeper and unearth the truth. One’s susceptibility to doctored information (and, by extension, false memories) may increase when untrue assertions are combined with accurate information. In society, these are often referred to as “half-truths,” but in general, something is either accurate or inaccurate, rather than somewhere in between.
False memory in clinical and legal contexts
False memories can lead to real challenges in daily life and extend beyond the individual, creating problems at a community level particularly within the justice system.
False memory syndrome (FMS)
False memory syndrome is a rare condition that is difficult to diagnose and can be confused with psychotic disorders. FMS features vivid memories of trauma, most commonly childhood sexual abuse, which the person firmly believes to be true even when objectively false. FMS as a concept is controversial, as it can be connected to recovered memory therapy, in which suggestibility is thought to play a role in the formation of these false memories.
Eyewitness testimony and wrongful convictions
False memories have played a large role in wrongful convictions over the years. Scientists have found that eyewitness testimony (widely used in convictions), can be unreliable and subject to false memories. Not only can heightened stress, emotion, and existing biases color the memory, but when questioned by authority figures, individuals may be highly susceptible to suggestion. Social psychology continues to study how eyewitness accounts can lead to false convictions.
False memory and mental health
As mentioned earlier, individuals with certain mental health conditions can be subject to distorted memories. If untreated or unaddressed, these distortions can create negative feedback loops that may exacerbate symptoms. For example, someone with social anxiety may think about a party they attended and recall a group of people laughing at them, even though this wasn’t what really happened. As they color the situation with their anxious feelings and biases, they may become even more fearful about the next social situation.
Can false memories be corrected or prevented?
There may be some effective steps to combat untrue memories. First, we should generally practice immediate and critical evaluation of what is being communicated. False memories may take time to form and internalize within the human mind. However, doctored information can be combated by considering the source.
Evaluating trustworthy sources against false memory
If the source of information is untrustworthy or otherwise suspicious, taking this source at its word may not be the most strategic move. A discerning mind can be one of the most powerful weapons against inaccurate information and false memories.
Questioning to combat false memories
Another productive manner of working against false information and false memories may be by asking questions of the source. If something does not sound right or appears suspicious, questioning can be a great way to pick apart the source and determine whether it may be spreading faulty information.
Practical takeaways for everyday life
Memory mistakes cannot be entirely avoided, but by understanding how they can occur and practicing mindfulness and incorporating cognitive exercises into your daily life, you may be able to reduce memory distortions.
Recognizing and minimizing memory errors
The first step can be to recognize that a false memory can happen to anyone, and to acknowledge that you may not always remember things accurately. Be willing to admit a mistake if the evidence is against you, and make an effort to examine your own biases. Try to experience each moment as it occurs, and to focus on any task at hand rather than scrolling through your phone or trying to do several things at once.
Minimizing suggestibility and influence from external sources
Find trusted sources of news and information to avoid implanted memories. This may take some time, but aim to rely on established media, scientific bodies, and professionals in their sphere. You may want to look to two or three sources and weigh the evidence you find. Try to avoid sources that use inflammatory language, or seek emotional response.
Mental exercises for older adults
Cognitive exercises can also help, especially for older adults. Here are some ideas to improve your brain processing at any age:
- Create a “memory palace” by associating things that you want to remember with certain locations in a familiar space, like your home
- Mindfulness exercises like meditation can help your brain to slow down and process stimuli more intentionally
- Critically evaluate your memories, asking yourself questions to determine how events actually unfolded
- Use sensory encoding by associating your memories with a sound, smell, or feeling to create greater strength and accuracy
- Get regular physical activity
- Play brain games like crossword puzzles, sudoku, or chess
- Prioritize getting regular, quality sleep
Therapy to address false memories
Therapy can be a great combatant against false memories, and it may also aid in the recovery of true recollections.
Sometimes, it can be challenging or uncomfortable to meet with a therapist in person for sessions. However, online therapy can be an excellent alternative to in-office therapy. It can empower you to get the professional help and guidance you deserve from the comfort and safety of your home, without having to worry about transportation or sitting in a crowded waiting room.
Effectiveness of online therapy
Studies have demonstrated that online therapy can be as effective as traditional, in-person therapy. Surveys have also shown that many people feel more comfortable expressing things via an online video call than they would face-to-face. Whether you prefer to connect with a therapist online or in person, you may rest assured that you’ll receive the qualified, professional help you deserve.
Getting started with BetterHelp is simple:
- Take a short questionnaire. Answer a few quick questions about your goals, preferences, and the type of therapist you’d like to work with.
- Get matched quickly. In most cases, you can be matched with a licensed provider in as little as 48 hours.
- Start therapy on your terms. Schedule sessions by video, phone, or live chat, and join from anywhere you have an internet connection.
Finding the right therapist isn’t just important – it’s everything.
Find your matchTakeaway
What causes false memory?
False memories are memories of events that did not actually occur or are memories that are distorted from what actually happened. Several factors and cognitive processes can cause the brain to create false memories:
- Suggestion and Leading Questions: External suggestions or leading questions from others can influence memory. When individuals are repeatedly asked about a certain event or are provided with misleading information, they may come to believe that the suggested event actually occurred.
- Misinformation Effect: Exposure to inaccurate information after an event can alter one's memory of the original event. This can happen through media reports, conversations with others, or even one's own speculation.
- Imagination Inflation: When individuals vividly imagine an event that did not happen, they may begin to incorporate this imagined experience into their memory as if it were real. Over time, the line between imagination and reality can become blurred.
- Source Confusion: Sometimes, people have difficulty distinguishing between the source of a memory. They may confuse a dream, a story they heard, or something they imagined with an actual memory.
- Suggestibility: Some individuals are more susceptible to suggestion and external influences on their memory. This can be influenced by personality traits or suggestibility tests.
- Cognitive Biases: Cognitive biases, such as confirmation bias (favoring information that confirms existing beliefs) or consistency bias (altering memories to be consistent with current beliefs), can lead to the creation of false memories.
- Stress and Trauma: Stressful or traumatic events can impact memory accuracy. High levels of stress hormones, such as cortisol, can affect memory retrieval and lead to memory distortions. False childhood memories may be a result of trauma related to early childhood events or an emotional memory.
- Repressed Memories: In some cases, repressed memories that were forgotten for an extended period may resurface. These repressed and recovered memories can be distorted or confused with other experiences.
- Neurological Factors: Brain disorders or injuries can sometimes result in memory distortions or confabulations, where individuals fill in memory gaps with false information.
- Schemas and Expectations: People have cognitive schemas or mental frameworks that guide their perception of the world. These schemas can influence how they interpret and remember events, potentially leading to memory errors that align with their expectations.
What are false memories called?
False memories are often referred to as "confabulations" in the field of psychology and psychiatry. Confabulation is a term used to describe the production of fabricated or distorted memories that are believed to be true by the individual experiencing them. These false memories can range from minor distortions of actual events to entirely fabricated recollections of events that never occurred.
How do I know if a memory is false?
Distinguishing true and false memories can be challenging, as our brains often treat both types of memories similarly. However, there are some strategies and considerations that can help you assess whether a memory might be false:
- External Corroboration: If possible, check for external evidence or corroboration that supports or contradicts the memory. For example, look for photographs, documents, or witness accounts that relate to the event in question.
- Consistency with Known Facts: Assess whether the memory is consistent with other established facts or timelines. If the memory contradicts well-established information, it may be a false memory.
- Source of Information: Consider the source of the memory. Was the memory suggested or influenced by someone else, such as through leading questions or conversations? Memories that originate from external suggestions are more likely to be false.
- Vividness and Detail: False memories can sometimes be overly vivid and detailed. If a memory seems unusually clear or elaborate, it may be worth questioning.
- Confidence Level: Reflect on your confidence in the memory. Do you have a strong feeling that it's accurate, or are you unsure? Strong confidence doesn't necessarily guarantee accuracy, as false memories can feel just as real as true ones.
- Corroborating Witnesses: If others were present during the event, ask them about their recollections. Keep in mind that eyewitness testimony can also be fallible, but it can provide additional perspectives.
Is false memory a mental illness in psychology?
In cognitive psychology, false memory itself is not a mental illness, but it can be a symptom or manifestation of certain mental health conditions or cognitive disorders. False memories are instances where individuals recall events or details that did not occur or are distorted from reality. These memory illusions can arise due to various cognitive processes and external influences, and they may not be inherently indicative of mental illness.
However, false memories can be associated with certain conditions or situations, including:
- Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD): Individuals with PTSD may experience intrusive and distressing memories that can sometimes be distorted or confused with actual events. These memories can contribute to the emotional distress associated with the disorder.
- Dissociative Disorders: Some dissociative disorders may lead an individual to form false memories. These disorders may involve disruptions in memory, identity, or consciousness, and individuals with dissociative disorders may experience memory gaps or the emergence of false or altered memories as part of their condition.
- Neurological Conditions: Certain neurological conditions, such as Alzheimer's disease, Korsakoff's syndrome, and other forms of dementia, can lead to memory distortions, including confabulations (false memories).
- Cognitive Disorders: Conditions that affect cognitive function, such as schizophrenia or delusional disorder, may involve false beliefs or memories as part of their symptomatology.
- Suggestion and Suggestibility: External suggestion or influence can lead to the creation of false memories. This can happen in therapy, legal contexts, or other situations where individuals may be particularly susceptible to suggestion.
What is false memory syndrome in psychology?
One condition debated in clinical and experimental psychology is False Memory Syndrome. False Memory Syndrome (FMS) is a controversial and debated concept in psychology and psychiatry. It refers to a condition in which individuals come to believe and vividly recall traumatic events, often of a sexual or abusive nature, that are later found to be false or unsupported by objective evidence. Proponents of the concept argue that these false memories can be induced by suggestive therapeutic techniques, leading individuals to create elaborate and emotionally charged narratives of events that did not occur.
Critics argue that FMS lacks empirical support or experimental and clinical evidence as a distinct syndrome and emphasize that memory errors and the potential for suggestion are well-known aspects of human memory. The debate surrounding FMS highlights the complexities of memory and the challenges of assessing the veracity of traumatic memories in therapeutic contexts.
Can false memories affect legal cases or eyewitness testimony?
Yes, they can. How the human mind recalls information can be distorted by a number of factors, and this can be especially prevalent in high-stress situations. Eyewitness testimony is often criticized for inaccuracy and false accusation.
How does the brain create false memories?
For most people, the brain does not offer perfect recall. Our memories can be influenced by our own biases, schemas, and even by things like suggestions from outside sources and emotional stress.
Can overthinking or anxiety contribute to false memories?
Yes, overthinking and anxiety can contribute to false memories. Cortisol, a hormone released when a person is experiencing high levels of stress, can impair memory consolidation. Rumination can encourage the brain to “fill in the blanks” of memory with a replayed and often distorted mental review.
What is the Mandela effect and how is it related to false memory?
The Mandela Effect is another way to refer to a collective false memory. Large groups of people incorrectly remember an event or detail in popular culture, even though it never happened. The phenomenon is named after Nelson Mandela, as a group of people believed he died in prison in the 1980s, although he was released and did not die until 2013, a free man.
Can false childhood memories be recovered accurately?
Yes, through critical reflection, and in some cases therapy, a person may correct a false memory.
- Previous Article
- Next Article