The term “dichotomous thinking,” often called “black and white thinking,” discusses a pattern of thought that views everything as an either-or situation. In other words, someone prone to dichotomous thinking may often see situations as all “good” or all “bad,” or all “right” and all “wrong” with no in-between or a grey area.
While anyone can experience dichotomous thinking, it can indicate a mental health condition or underlying challenge if it persists in the long term and negatively impacts work, school, and relationships. Because there is no room for a “grey area” with this type of thinking, extreme outcomes can seem the only possible scenario to those experiencing it, which can make many areas of life feel stressful or unpredictable.
Mental Health And Dichotomous Thinking
While dichotomous thinking may not indicate an underlying mental health condition, it can be a symptom of a few.
Dichotomous thinking is often considered a type of cognitive distortion, which may skew one’s perception of an expected outcome rather than what might occur. Cognitive distortions are often the result of an attempt to simplify, understand, or reduce the impacts of a distressing situation. The brain takes past information and can form related associations, allowing individuals to experience cognitive distortions whenever a similar situation or stimulus arises.
Examples Of Dichotomous Thinking
If you’re looking to apply for a job but are prone to dichotomous thinking, you might feel your only options are to get the first job you interview for or remain unemployed. You may not be aware that your mind is relying on these two options. The result, though, can be intense anxiety about the interview, self-doubt, and fear. Because you’ve placed so much weight on the interview as the only alternative to your worst possible outcome, your stress may impact your performance at the interview, further solidifying your belief that you are not cut out for any job, whereas you may be qualified for many jobs.
Dichotomous thinking may be subtle and go unnoticed, but it can also make celebrating your successes and improving your self-esteem challenging. For example, perhaps you had a goal to finish ten projects at work by the end of the week. At the end of the week, you accomplished eight. For many people, a slight disappointment might arise, but not enough to change the conclusion that accomplishing eight projects can be a positive start.
For someone who experiences dichotomous thinking, there is no grey area. Instead, they may only see success and failure. If you’re experiencing dichotomous thinking and complete only eight projects out of ten, you might consider yourself a failure, start panicking about losing your job, or feel that you are flawed in some way. These thoughts can cause anxiety, stress, and depression.
The Impacts Of Dichotomous Thinking
Thinking only of success or total failure can lead to stress, low self-esteem, and the development of mental illnesses like depression and generalized anxiety disorder (GAD). Spending time thinking that you’ve failed, even when you’ve made a valiant effort, can feel like self-punishment. If you can view a problem as it is, with the option of having a “grey area,” you may feel more motivated to change your strategies to do better next time. If you believe you are a failure, you might want to give up without trying again, even if you have the potential to better yourself.
Why Do Some Mental Illnesses Cause Dichotomous Thinking?
Dichotomous thinking is a symptom of many mental health conditions, including borderline personality disorder. However, it can happen to anyone. For many people, dichotomous thinking occurs because they have no other frame of reference. For some, growing up and having life experiences removes these opinions that there are only two sides to the story. Many people can reframe their thoughts and find a middle ground. However, those with borderline personality disorder and other mental illnesses may struggle to develop this understanding at first due to their mental health symptoms.
Extreme mood swings, risky or impulsive behavior, and bursts of anger can make life situations seem extreme and lacking in subjectivity. The same cognitive distortions that may stem from or contribute to mental health symptoms can play a role in perpetuating dichotomous thinking. However, by developing problem-solving and positive self-talk skills, among other treatment techniques, it can be possible to manage these symptoms and learn to take control of dichotomous thinking.
How To Find Support For Dichotomous Thinking
There are different ways to go about treatment for dichotomous thinking. For many, the first step involves understanding and recognizing that it is occurring. Many people don’t know they’re experiencing all-or-nothing thought patterns because the process is often subconscious. Making cognitive distortions a conscious thought process can help you address them long-term.
When you finish a task, think about it consciously; take a step back to process your feelings. It may help to jot your thoughts into a journal or discuss them with a loved one. Doing so may allow you to recognize whether you’re reflecting on what you’ve done or thinking in black and white. Often, you might find that your fear, stress, or anger stems from assumptions about right and wrong, good and bad, or success and failure.
Anyone can seek professional support for dichotomous thinking, regardless of diagnostic status or mental health. Having a supportive professional that you can work through your thoughts with can provide perspective, encouragement, and support. For many, online therapy is one of the most effective ways to receive this type of support, as it can be done from the safety and comfort of your own home. In addition, many online therapists can offer worksheets that can be printed out or filled out during or after the session, allowing the lessons in the session to stay fresh in your mind.
Online therapy can also focus on much more than dichotomous thinking and is as effective as in-person therapy for managing mental health conditions. When you work with an online therapist, you can target specific goals like developing positive self-talk, improving your self-esteem, or re-training your mind to find the grey area in situations where you might have struggled before. If you want to speak to a therapist about cognitive distortions, an online platform like BetterHelp can match you with an expert in cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) to support you.
What is an example of a dichotomous reasoning?
Dichotomous reasoning, also known as black-or-white thinking or all-or-nothing thinking, involves perceiving situations as having only two extreme options, without considering any middle ground or nuances. Here's an example of dichotomous reasoning:
Imagine someone receives a performance evaluation at work. They receive some constructive feedback along with positive comments about their achievements. A person engaging in dichotomous reasoning might respond by thinking:
"I got some negative feedback on my performance evaluation, so I must be a total failure at my job. I can't do anything right."
In this example, the person is viewing their performance evaluation in black-and-white terms. They're disregarding any positive aspects or evidence of good work and interpreting the feedback as an indication of total failure. They're not considering the possibility that there might be areas for improvement while also recognizing their accomplishments.
Is dichotomous thinking a mental illness?
Dichotomous thinking is not a mental illness in and of itself. Instead, it's a cognitive distortion or thinking pattern that can be associated with various mental health conditions, including anxiety disorders, depression, borderline personality disorder, and certain types of eating disorders.
Dichotomous thinking involves perceiving situations in extremes, without considering middle ground or nuances. While it's a common human cognitive bias that everyone experiences from time to time, it becomes problematic when it becomes a habitual way of interpreting the world.
What are examples of dichotomous thinking in psychology?
Dichotomous thinking, also referred to as all-or-nothing thinking or black-and-white thinking, involves viewing situations as having only two extreme options without considering any middle ground or shades of gray. This cognitive distortion can lead to oversimplified and distorted perceptions of reality. Here are some examples of dichotomous thinking in psychology:
- Relationships: "If my friend doesn't call me back immediately, they must not care about me at all." This example ignores the possibility that there might be various reasons for the delay in communication.
- Academic Performance: "If I don't get a perfect score on this test, I'm a complete failure." This thinking ignores the possibility of incremental improvement and the fact that one test does not define a person's worth.
- Self-Esteem: "If someone criticizes my work, it means I'm worthless and incompetent." This thinking doesn't consider the idea that receiving feedback is a normal part of growth and improvement.
- Appearance: "If I don't look perfect, then I'm unattractive and no one will like me." This example ignores the fact that beauty and attractiveness are subjective, and self-worth isn't solely based on physical appearance.
- Social Interactions: "If I'm not the life of the party, then I'm boring and nobody wants to be around me." This thinking disregards the fact that different social situations call for different levels of engagement.
- Success and Failure: "If I don't succeed at everything I do, I'm a total failure." This mindset doesn't acknowledge that success and failure are part of everyone's journey and that growth often comes from setbacks.
- Emotions: "If I'm feeling anxious, it means I'm weak and incapable of handling life." This thinking ignores the normal fluctuations of emotions and the fact that everyone experiences anxiety at times.
- Goals and Achievements: "If I didn't achieve my goal exactly as planned, it means I'm a loser." This example discounts the progress made and the effort put into working toward the goal.
Dichotomous thinking can lead to negative self-perceptions, interpersonal problems, increased stress, and difficulty in coping with challenges. Research has shown that recognizing these patterns and challenging them through cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) and other therapeutic approaches is an effective way to reduce the tendency to use dichotomous thinking.
What are the characteristics of a dichotomous thinker?
Dichotomous thinkers exhibit a specific cognitive style characterized by viewing situations in extreme, polarized terms without considering middle ground or nuances. While everyone engages in dichotomous thinking occasionally, some individuals consistently demonstrate this pattern of thought. Here are some characteristics of a dichotomous thinker:
- Extreme Thinking: Dichotomous thinkers tend to perceive situations as either completely good or completely bad, with no room for anything in between.
- Limited Perspective: They have difficulty seeing shades of gray or considering multiple factors that might contribute to a situation. Their thinking is rigid and inflexible.
- Absence of Middle Ground: They struggle to acknowledge that situations can be complex and multifaceted. There's a tendency to focus on only the positive or negative aspects.
- Catastrophic Thinking: They might jump to the worst-case scenario when faced with challenges. Minor setbacks can feel like complete failures to them.
- Emotional Extremes: Dichotomous thinkers often experience intense emotional reactions. They may feel elated when things go well and deeply devastated when things don't go as planned.
- Perfectionism: They might hold themselves and others to unrealistic standards. Anything short of perfection can be seen as a failure.
- Self-Criticism: They may be overly self-critical, believing that any mistakes or shortcomings define their entire identity and worth.
- Difficulty Handling Ambiguity: Ambiguous situations or uncertain outcomes can be distressing for dichotomous thinkers because they prefer clear-cut answers.
- Impulsivity: When faced with decisions, they might rush to make choices without considering potential options or consequences.
- Intolerance of Uncertainty: Uncertainty and unpredictability can lead to anxiety and stress for dichotomous thinkers, as they prefer clear and certain outcomes.
- Relationship Struggles: They might have difficulty navigating relationships due to their tendency to perceive people as either all good or all bad.
- Judgmental Attitude: Dichotomous thinkers might quickly judge others based on limited information, categorizing them as either likeable or unlikeable.
What causes dichotomous thinking?
Dichotomous thinking, also known as black-and-white thinking or all-or-nothing thinking, can stem from various psychological and cognitive factors. It's a cognitive distortion that distorts perceptions of reality by oversimplifying situations into extreme, polarized categories. Several factors can contribute to the development and reinforcement of dichotomous thinking:
- Cognitive Biases: Human brains are wired to simplify information for quick decision-making. This can lead to dichotomous thinking as a way to process complex situations more easily, even if it doesn't accurately represent reality.
- Emotional Factors: Intense emotions can contribute to dichotomous thinking. When emotions are strong, it's common to perceive situations in extreme terms to match the emotional intensity.
- Perfectionism: Individuals with perfectionistic tendencies often view outcomes as either perfect or complete failures. This mindset can lead to dichotomous thinking in various areas of life.
- Insecurity: People who struggle with low self-esteem may engage in black-and-white thinking to protect themselves from potential failures or criticism. This can lead to a fear of making mistakes.
- Anxiety: Anxiety can lead to catastrophic thinking, where individuals focus on worst-case scenarios or consequences. This can contribute to dichotomous thinking by magnifying potential negative outcomes.
To determine if an individual implements dichotomous thinking, a mental health professional may use a variety of surveys or tests beginning with the Dichotomous Thinking Inventory (DTI). If a person is stuck in a pattern of dichotomous thinking, having their thinking challenged through cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) or other forms of therapy may be beneficial.
What is the difference between dichotomous and dialectical thinking?
Dichotomous thinking and dialectical thinking are two distinct cognitive approaches that involve different ways of perceiving and processing information. They represent opposite ends of a cognitive spectrum. Here's the difference between the two:
Dichotomous thinking, also known as black-and-white thinking or all-or-nothing thinking, involves seeing situations in extreme, polarized terms. Individuals who engage in dichotomous thinking tend to view things as either completely good or completely bad, without considering any middle ground or nuances. This type of thinking can lead to oversimplification of complex situations and can contribute to negative emotions, rigid thought patterns, and difficulties in problem-solving.
For example, if someone makes a small mistake at work, a dichotomous thinker might view themselves as a total failure and disregard any positive aspects of their performance.
Dialectical thinking, on the other hand, involves holding opposing viewpoints or contradictory ideas in mind simultaneously and finding ways to synthesize or reconcile them. It's characterized by an ability to recognize that situations are often complex and multifaceted, and that there can be shades of gray between black and white. Dialectical thinkers are comfortable with ambiguity and uncertainty and are open to exploring various perspectives.
For example, when faced with a disagreement, a dialectical thinker might acknowledge their own viewpoint while also considering the validity of the other person's perspective, seeking a compromise or common ground.
What are the dangers of dichotomous thinking?
Dichotomous thinking can have several negative consequences on a person's mental and emotional well-being, as well as their ability to effectively navigate life's challenges. Here are some dangers associated with dichotomous thinking:
- Emotional Distress: Viewing situations in extreme terms can lead to heightened emotional reactions. Small setbacks or failures may be perceived as catastrophic, leading to intense feelings of anxiety, depression, frustration, or anger.
- Negative Self-Image: Dichotomous thinkers often judge themselves harshly based on their perceived successes or failures. This can contribute to low self-esteem and a negative self-concept.
- Impaired Decision-Making: Dichotomous thinking limits the consideration of alternatives and middle ground. This can hinder effective decision-making, as individuals might struggle to weigh pros and cons objectively.
- Relationship Struggles: Interpersonal relationships require understanding and compromise. Dichotomous thinkers might struggle to navigate disagreements or misunderstandings, leading to strained relationships.
- Rigidity: This type of thinking can lead to rigid thought patterns, making it difficult to adapt to changing situations or consider new perspectives.
- Fear of Failure: Fear of failure is amplified when everything is perceived as either a success or a failure. This can prevent individuals from taking risks or pursuing goals.
- Perfectionism: Dichotomous thinkers might strive for perfection, as anything less is seen as failure. This can lead to excessive stress and burnout.
- Inflexible Problem-Solving: Complex problems often require creative and flexible solutions. Dichotomous thinkers might struggle to find innovative approaches.
- Ineffective Coping: Dichotomous thinkers might struggle to cope with setbacks and stressors. They may lack the resilience to bounce back from challenges.
- Limited Perspective: Dichotomous thinking narrows one's view of the world, preventing them from seeing the gray areas and complexities of life.
- Us-vs-Them Mentality: This type of thinking can contribute to an "us vs. them" mentality, where individuals categorize others as either with them or against them, hindering constructive communication and lowering respect.
- Previous Article
- Next Article