Attachment-Based Therapy: Evidence-Based Practices
By: Toni Hoy
Updated March 17, 2021
Medically Reviewed By: Lauren Guilbeault
If you think about the many relationships that you have in your life and their importance to your happiness and well-being, it's easy to see why attachment-based therapy is critical for people who live with attachment disorders.
Attachment-based therapy encompasses some fairly new therapies for treating attachment disorders. Attachment disorders are serious conditions that affect children beginning at young age. If left untreated, attachment disorders can affect individuals and their relationships for a lifetime.
John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth were some of the early pioneers on attachment-based therapy. "A Review of General Psychology" survey (2002) ranked Bowlby as the 49th most-cited psychologists of the 20th century.
Research has given us some insight as to some dangerous types of attachment-based therapies. More importantly, researchers continue to make progress in understanding the types of attachment-based therapies that are beginning to show promising results.
To date, healing for attachment-based disorders focusses on understanding and strengthening the relationship between a child and his or her primary caregivers.
What Are Attachment Disorders?
Attachment disorders are psychiatric illnesses that develop in very young children as characterized by their inability or difficulty in emotionally attaching to others. The illness is nearly always due to infant or toddler severe neglect or abuse.
Children who lacked early primary caregivers such as those who lived in orphanages, residential centers, or those who had multiple foster care placements where care was abusive or neglectful often develop attachment disorders. Children who've experienced multiple traumatic losses may also develop attachment-based disorders.
According to the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, symptoms of attachment-based disorders may appear within the first year of life and may persist or exacerbate as the child gets older. Symptoms include:
- Severe colic and feeding difficulties
- Failure to gain weight
- Detached and unresponsive behavior
- Difficulty being comforted
- Preoccupied and defiant behavior
- Inhibition or hesitancy in social interactions
- Being too close with strangers
Attachment-based disorders can develop into Reactive Attachment Disorder or Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder.
What Is Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD)?
Reactive Attachment Disorder (RAD) is a brain disorder where children have had negative experiences with adults during their early years, and their natural inclination is to disassociate with them. Children living with RAD don't naturally seek out a loving adult when they're stressed, upset, or feeling unregulated. The illness is characterized by a child having little or no emotions when they interact with other children, their parents, or other adults. Children living with RAD experience intermittent and unusually strong emotions of unhappiness, irritability, depression, and fear without having the ability to comfort them. Chronic symptoms of severe emotional irregularity combined with a history of trauma indicate a diagnosis of RAD.
What Is Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder (DSED)?
A child who is overly friendly with strangers is indicative of Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder. Such children aren't afraid of meeting people for the first time. They may walk up to them, talk to them, or even hug them. Very young children may be comfortable allowing strange adults to hold them and talk with them, feed them, and play with them.
When these children are put in a situation with strangers, they don't check with their parents or caregivers for assurance and are often willing to go away with someone they don't know at all.
Controversy Over Holding Therapies
In their efforts to heal children from early trauma and attachment disorders, a handful of therapists devised and practiced holding therapy or rebirthing therapies.
The premise behind holding therapy was that the way to heal children who weren't able to bond and attach to their parents or primary caregivers was for the caregiver to hold the child tightly so that they'd eventually become comfortable with the sense of touch and hugs.
Along the same lines, therapists developed "rebirthing" strategies that were intended to simulate the process of being reborn. The concept was for the child to essentially go back in time and re-experience the feelings of warmth, care, and closeness that they should have received as infants and toddlers.
For some children, both methods resulted in several child deaths. These practices were quickly banned by state legislatures and professional organizations such as the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, the American Professional Society on the Abuse of Children, the American Psychiatric Association, and the American Psychology Association. These organizations have all published warnings regarding these types of harmful treatments.
Evidence-Based Attachment Therapy
Reactive Attachment Disorder and Disinhibited Social Engagement Disorder are serious clinical conditions, and their treatments are not yet well-researched.
What we do know is that individuals who are seeking effective treatment for these disorders need to request a comprehensive psychiatric assessment and individualized treatment plan by a qualified mental health professional.
The best treatments for children living with attachment-based disorders involves treating their parents and other family members as well because the premise behind the child's healing requires developing and strengthening relationships between the child and his or her parents and siblings. Parents should expect an ongoing collaboration between the family and the treatment team to increase the likelihood of a successful outcome.
There are currently no evidence-based therapies for attachment-based disorders because researchers haven't had the time to repeated studies or longitudinal studies. According to California
Evidence-Based Clearing House for Child Welfare, the best we have at this time is two programs with a Scientific Rating of 3, which means they are categorized as Promising Research Evidence. Those programs are Child-Parent Relationship Therapy and Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy (DDP). Let's take a closer look at each one of them.
Child-Parent Relationship Therapy
Child-Parent Relationship Therapy (CPRT) is an attachment-based therapy that works best for children aged 3-8 who live with behavioral, social, and attachment disorders. This treatment is play-therapy based and is a systemic intervention that is based on attachment principles, Child-Centered Play Therapy (CCPT), and interpersonal neurobiology.
The central idea behind CPRT is that it's essential for a child's well-being to have a secure relationship with a primary caregiver. This is a two part-therapy where children can learn to count on their parents to meet their basic life needs of love, acceptance, safety, security, food, and shelter. At the same time, parents learn skills that help them respond to their children in ways that establish or enhance feelings of secure attachment with their children. Parents learn how to respond to the child's needs as opposed to reacting to a child's symptoms. The goals of the therapy are to:
- Increase trust, security, and closeness between the child, parents, and other family members
- Improve child/parent communication
- Develop problem-solving strategies within the family
- Increase affection and enjoyment in relationships
- Increase parental empathy and acceptance
- Improve parent's ability to attune and respond to children
- Help parents develop realistic limits and expectations
- Boost parents' self-confidence in parenting
- Increase children's ability to express their needs and feelings in an appropriate way
- Encourage children to express and regulate their emotions in appropriate ways
Therapists may work with children and their parents in a variety of settings including hospitals, clinics, schools, community centers, and the family's home.
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy (DDP)
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy is an attachment-based therapy with a target population of families with children or adolescents aged 5-17. Children that live with attachment disorders and trauma who meet the DSM-V criteria for Reactive Attachment Disorder, trauma-related diagnoses, and those who meet the clinical criteria for Complex Trauma, which is also known as Developmental Trauma Disorder are typically good candidates for DDP.
DDP is a type of therapy that was designed for the treatment of children who experienced neglect, abuse, and multiple placements. The concept is that when a child's early experiences of attachment to their primary caregivers are abusive, neglectful, or inconsistent, they don't have the opportunity to experience a reciprocal (dyadic) relationship that is necessary for healthy development. The benefit of a foster or adoptive home with healthy parenting styles may help a child to overcome past abusive or neglectful relationships by encouraging them to trust and engage with the new caregiver. The most traumatized children have greater difficulty in bonding with their new parents, and DDP enhances their ability to accept being parented.
DDP is grounded in a foundation of playfulness, acceptance, curiosity, and empathy. DDP practices never involve coercion, threat, intimidation, or the use of power to force a child into submission.
The goals of DDP for children include:
- Helping children develop a more secure pattern of attachment
- Resolving symptoms of trauma
- Strengthening the child's relationship with the primary caregiver
The goals of DDP for parents or primary caregivers are:
- To be in greater attunement with child
- To reflect more deeply on their responses to their child
- To approach their child with attachment-facilitating techniques
- To become more sensitive
Three other programs are developing as attachment-based therapies. They are not rated at this time because not enough studies have been completed to consider them as evidence-based. These attachment-based therapies include:
- Corrective Attachment Therapy
- Healing Hearts Camp
- Trust-Based Relational Intervention Therapeutic Camp
In the quest to heal children from issues related to trauma and attachment, new therapies have been emerging over the last decade. Evidence-based practices are emerging as trust-based, relationship-centered interventions which have not proven to be dangerous or harmful to children.
Previous Article9 Things To Look For In An Anxiety Therapist
Next ArticleWhat Is A Cognitive Behavioral Therapist? And Should I See One?
Learn MoreWhat Is Online Therapy? About Online Counseling
Abuse ADHD Adolescence Alzheimer's Ambition Anger Anxiety Attachment Attraction Behavior Bipolar Body Dysmorphic Disorder Body Language Bullying Careers Chat Childhood Counseling Dating Defense Mechanisms Dementia Depression Domestic Violence Eating Disorders Family Friendship General Grief Guilt Happiness How To Huntington's Disease Impulse Control Disorder Intimacy Loneliness Love Marriage Medication Memory Menopause MidLife Crisis Mindfulness Monogamy Morality Motivation Neuroticism Optimism Panic Attacks Paranoia Parenting Personality Personality Disorders Persuasion Pessimism Pheromones Phobias Pornography Procrastination Psychiatry Psychologists Psychopathy Psychosis Psychotherapy PTSD Punishment Rejection Relationships Resilience Schizophrenia Self Esteem Sleep Sociopathy Stage Fright Stereotypes Stress Success Stories Synesthesia Teamwork Teenagers Temperament Tests Therapy Time Management Trauma Visualization Willpower Wisdom Worry
Understanding The Difference: How Is Behavior Therapy Different Than Psychoanalysis What Is Cognitive Behavior Therapy? What Not to Say To Your Therapist: How To Make The Most Of Your Therapy Sessions Therapy Apps For You Thera-Link Review: Is It A Worthwhile Therapy Service Talkspace Review: How Does It Hold Up?