The Paradox Of Getting Over Someone You Never Dated

By Dylan Buckley|Updated August 4, 2022

Ending a relationship with someone we dated can take a toll on our emotional wellbeing. This type of loss can leave a hole in our lives that will take time to heal. But there are also those experiencing a similar sense of loss, except with someone they never actually dated. When we're trying to get over a relationship that might have been but never quite was, things can become complicated. Learn how to get over a crush in this article to gain some peace back.

Are You Missing A Relationship That You Never Really Had?

I Never Dated Them, So Why Do I Feel This Way? Can You Be Heartbroken Over An Unrealized Relationship?

As strange as it might sound, getting over someone you never dated, according to experts, can be just as hard as a breakup. You can experience similar feelings: grief, sadness, frustration, rejection, disappointment, confused, and fear. You may find yourself so upset over this ending that you are constantly crying, you are depressed, or overall feeling lost. If you are longing and yearning to get over these emotions, this article can help provide some tips to focus on self-care and get your energy back.

With someone you never actually dated, according to experts you may unintentionally put them on a pedestal and assume it would have been a wonderful match, when in reality it may not have been. You also might be missing closure on this decision of theirs, wondering where the signs were that this was coming to an end, with nothing to grasp on to. The rejection or loss of a potentially real and meaningful relationship can be hard to handle, but just like with a traditional breakup, you can heal and find a healthy way to move forward. We'll talk more about how you can overcome these issues throughout the article, and how to regain self-esteem and get out of the sorrowful anguish you are feeling.

How Do You Get Over Someone You Never Dated?

What would lead to a situation where you experience the paradox of getting over someone you never dated? Maybe you fell for a friend who didn't have the same feelings. Maybe you grew feelings for a coworker who was unavailable, or maybe you never had the nerve to explore your feelings for someone and tell them how you felt. Or maybe you were seeing someone and everything was pointing to them eventually becoming your partner, but you never got the chance. Everyone has experienced something like this, and there are steps (often lists and advice) to grow from these experiences and regain your strength.

No matter the situation, you have no way of knowing. This is something you will want to remind yourself as you move through the process of getting over this person – you do not know that it would have worked out or been a good fit for you despite how it feels right now. It will not help your healing process if you spend time continuing to fantasize.

That said, it is extremely important to acknowledge your feelings. Your family and friends might say, "why are you so sad? It's not like you were ever together." They may be well intentioned and trying to help, but this is not helpful. It will only make the recovery process longer and harder if you minimize your feelings. It is important you don't deny your feelings or tell yourself it doesn't matter because you were never "official." Pain is pain and it is not always logical. If you need to cry, cry. If you are hurt or suffering, allow yourself some time to just feel miserable or remorseful, otherwise it might show up in other ways later on. Give yourself permission to reach out to your support network and tell them what you need. However, make sure you don't stay in the pining and regretful stage for too long. Maybe you need to go out, have fun, and start to move forward from the relationship you realized you will never have by focusing on the future. Meeting other guys, other people can at the very least make a good story, and these stories can lead to a goal, you finding out some truth about yourself and what you want, or just a fun time with others. First, take the time you need to grieve and talk about what you feel you are missing.

How To Get Over Them

Journaling is a great coping skill if you do not feel like talking. You can write about your feelings and thoughts, anything that is capturing your attention through a photo, image, or just a bunch of words. If you are experiencing lack of touch, trouble with sleep, annoyance at dating apps, or overall a lose of sense of "team", get it out. Anytime you are able to get thoughts and feelings out of your head and onto paper, you can make progress with healing. Be kind to yourself as you heal and do not set a timeline for when you need to be "over it." Allow yourself to feel. It is important that you do positive things that make you feel good. It can be a good idea to seek new hobbies and activities for self-growth and improvement. You can use this time to work on being the best version of yourself.

If this person is a friend who doesn't have the same romantic feelings for you, have an honest conversation with that friend and determine whether or not you can continue the friendship. It might be too painful for you to do so, or you might want to take a break while you heal. The other person might feel too uncomfortable, as well. While a conversation of this nature might feel awkward, try not to be embarrassed. It could help salvage your friendship so that you do not lose a friend. Be proud of yourself for allowing yourself to be vulnerable with your feelings.

Are You Missing A Relationship That You Never Really Had?

Another option is to sit with your feelings for a period of time and see if they fade. For example, if you develop an infatuation with a co-worker who is married or is unavailable, pause to examine what is going on in your life. Maybe you feel lonely and are ready to start a relationship and see this person as someone who would be a solution to your loneliness or desire for a relationship. Perhaps if you give yourself permission to be honest with yourself and figure out what is at the root of the feelings, you can focus on meeting new people and dating, rather than let the feelings for this co-worker grow and grow and potentially become more irrational and idealistic.

Counseling can be helpful in this process, as well as leaning on the support of your friends. You also want to check in with yourself and make sure you are not feeling so down that you are unable to enjoy life and meet your regular obligations.

What To Do If This Happens Often

While it is not abnormal to fall for someone who doesn't return your feelings or someone you never dated, according to experts, it might be helpful to examine why if you find yourself in this situation often. Are you afraid of rejection, so you find yourself fantasizing about people you know you will never date? Do you not think you are good enough for someone you are interested in, so you avoid putting yourself out there? Is dating overwhelming for you? There are many reasons that could lead to this happening often, and giving yourself permission to talk to a therapist can help you find the answers. It could also just be that you are ready to start a relationship and find yourself noticing any possibilities. If this is the case, you can talk with your counselor about healthy ways to meet people.

How To Cope With The Pain Of Rejection From Someone You Never Dated

Although it will take time to heal, there are helpful coping mechanisms that will allow you to handle the pain that comes with rejection. Here are some of the most helpful strategies that you can employ at home:

Stay Busy And Work Towards What You Want

Avoidance is not helpful in terms of healing but doing your best to keep your mind off of the situation can lessen your pain and help you move on. One great way to do this is to stay busy and focus on other parts of your life you want to advance. You will mostly get so wrapped up that you will easily forget about your crush and learn how to connect more with yourself, instead.

Connect With Friends And Loved Ones

Although you cannot have the person you may have wanted, you have people in your life who make you happy in a different capacity. Make a point to schedule more outings with friends and family to keep your mind off of your adverse feelings. While it’s important to allow yourself to feel and process those feelings, rumination can be harmful. It’s important to stay engaged in things you care about and still spend time with loved ones.

Give Yourself Permission To Get Back Out There

Don't let the pain of rejection prevent you from going after what you want. Give yourself permission to meet the many people out there who may connect with you and love you equally. If you really want to have that type of connection, get back on that horse and try again. (Just make sure you're emotionally ready for it!)

Mending The Wounds Of Getting Over Someone You Never Dated With BetterHelp

Your feelings are just as real and as valid as someone who is going through a breakup after a relationship. Don't let anyone minimize your feelings and need for support. It is important to understand why this has happened and the best way to heal. It is an important time to take care of yourself and allow yourself the space to heal and move forward. Communicating with a therapist such as those found at BetterHelp can be beneficial.

BetterHelp is an online counseling platform dedicated to providing people like you with access to certified therapists from the comfort of your own home and on your own time! You can get started immediately anywhere you have an internet connection, and there are a variety of ways you can communicate with your therapist: live chat, messages, video sessions, and phone calls. Below are some reviews of BetterHelp counselors from people experiencing similar issues.

Counselor Reviews

"In one session Douglas has helped me realize and find a way to break a pattern that I've been having for the last few weeks and probably lifelong. This is going to help me improve my relationships and my life will be more fulfilling. I'm glad I got to talk to Douglas, I can sense he is a great professional."

"Erin is AMAZING. I've been having a lot of relationship related anxiety issues and she has been what I needed to FINALLY break through my own negative thoughts. She is worth every penny spent and I couldn't recommend her more. She's fantastic."


While falling in love with someone you can't have can be difficult, you can still get over it as you would with any legitimate breakup. Take time for yourself, get the necessary help and support, and get out there so that you can meet someone who will reciprocate your affections. With the right tools, a fulfilling relationship is possible. Take the first step.

For Additional Help & Support With Your Concerns
Speak with a Licensed Therapist
The information on this page is not intended to be a substitution for diagnosis, treatment, or informed professional advice. You should not take any action or avoid taking any action without consulting with a qualified mental health professional. For more information, please read our terms of use.